How many arguments end with both people still believing the same things, and just hating each other more? You’ve seen it, I’ve seen it. People yell and rage at each other until they run out of steam and then they retreat into their respective corners to lick their wounds. The inevitable result is that while no one “wins” the argument, their disdain for the other side grows increasingly strong, and the next time the topic arises the furor with which it is debated is only stronger.
Pretty soon, all you have to do is mention the topic and all the sudden you are drowning in a sea of bile, which once expelled leaves everyone exhausted and in pain.
I saw this recently with gay rights. Someone posted, on Facebook, a fairly innocuous plea for people to show Christ’s love and compassion when discussing the recent outcry over Phil Robertson from Duck Dynasty’s comments. Within seconds, what unfolded was not a “he who is without sin may cast the first stone” show of support, but a heated and bloody argument that left the original poster in tears.
“What’s left,” another friend later said, “but the “unfriend” button?”
I have to wonder, whose needs are met by this disturbing trend? What is really being served? We often assume, when we retreat to our respective corners, that out there is a world that agrees with our assumptions. Yet today I’m feeling like it’s far more likely that we are actually alone.
I think we need to take a time out. I think instead of rushing from our corners like a prize fighter hungry to land the killing blow, we need to take the time to look around us and simply be aware. Who are we fighting? Why?
A dear friend of mine said, in the midst of the heated discussions of the past few days, that’s it’s easy to say something isn’t all that bad if it’s not being said about you. Often the kneejerk response to her quiet plea to be understood was further defensiveness or accusations that she simply took things to personally.
I have to wonder why, never once that I heard or saw, someone didn’t turn to her and ask, “can you help me understand why you’re upset?”
We need to keep our eyes and hearts open. Instead of viewing every argument as a chance to bury our own hatchets, why aren’t we seeing an argument as a chance to further our understanding of the world around us?
I believe this is doubly, triply, infinitely more true for Christians. After all, as Christians we act not as ambassadors of our past grudges but ambassadors of the love and grace of God. When we see an argument, our first response should never be to start drawing lines in the sand and throwing punches. We should see them as opportunities to express a unique grace and compassion, defending those who are in pain and showing compassion to our enemies.
So why are we still fighting?
Photo by Nasrulekram